🏫 Top 5 Catholic Elementary Schools in Pickering (2025)

When it comes to choosing the right elementary school for your child, Pickering, Ontario, offers an excellent range of Catholic education options that blend strong academics, moral values, and community spirit. Parents in 2025 are increasingly prioritizing schools that offer both educational excellence and a nurturing environment - and Pickering’s Catholic elementary schools deliver exactly that.

In this blog, we’ve shortlisted the Top 5 Catholic Elementary Schools in Pickering (2025) based on performance, reputation, facilities, and community feedback. Each of these schools provides a faith-based education while focusing on academic growth, inclusivity, and student development.

1. St. Mary Catholic Secondary School

📌 School Overview
St. Mary Catholic Secondary School is one of Pickering’s most respected Catholic institutions, known for its excellence in academics, athletics, and spiritual development. As part of the Durham Catholic District School Board (DCDSB), the school places strong emphasis on holistic education that integrates faith, knowledge, and service to others.

St. Mary’s offers a variety of programs, including STEM-focused learning, Advanced Placement (AP) courses, and Catholic character formation activities that help students grow into compassionate and responsible citizens. The campus features state-of-the-art facilities, modern classrooms, and vibrant extracurricular programs.

📊 Performance Snapshot (2025)

• Fraser Institute Rating: 8.7 / 10

• EQAO Math Success Rate: 91%

• Graduation Rate: 98%

• Student-Teacher Ratio: 18:1

🌟 Why It’s a Top Choice

• Strong Catholic identity and moral foundation

• Excellent academic results and student engagement

• Wide range of extracurricular activities

• Nurturing, inclusive, and diverse community

🏠 Nearby Communities
Families often choose to live in Amberlea, Liverpool, or Rosebank for their close proximity to St. Mary and family-friendly atmosphere.

👉 Explore homes near St. Mary Catholic Secondary School

2. St. Isaac Jogues Catholic School

📌 School Overview
Nestled in a peaceful Pickering neighbourhood, St. Isaac Jogues Catholic School is celebrated for its warm environment, academic integrity, and community involvement. It focuses on faith-based education while nurturing creativity and curiosity among students.

This elementary school follows the Ontario curriculum while embedding Catholic teachings into everyday learning. Its teachers are known for their personalized attention and support, helping each child reach their fullest potential - academically, socially, and spiritually.

📊 Performance Snapshot (2025)

• Fraser Institute Rating: 8.5 / 10

• EQAO Math Success Rate: 89%

• Literacy Rate: 93%

• Student-Teacher Ratio: 17:1

🌟 Why It’s a Top Choice

• Emphasis on compassion, respect, and community service

• Excellent parental involvement and communication

• Balanced approach to academics and moral education

• Safe and welcoming school environment

🏠 Nearby Communities
Families prefer Highbush, Rougemount, and West Shore neighbourhoods for easy school access and peaceful surroundings.

👉 Explore homes near St. Isaac Jogues Catholic School

3. St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic School

📌 School Overview
St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic School has earned its place among Pickering’s best elementary schools thanks to its outstanding academic record, dedicated staff, and community-focused approach. The school encourages every student to “Learn, Love, and Lead” through Catholic values.

Known for fostering leadership and curiosity from a young age, St. Elizabeth Seton’s classrooms integrate technology and experiential learning. Students engage in a variety of co-curricular programs, from choir and sports to robotics and social justice initiatives.

📊 Performance Snapshot (2025)

• Fraser Institute Rating: 8.6 / 10

• EQAO Math Success Rate: 90%

• Literacy Rate: 95%

• Average Class Size: 19 students

🌟 Why It’s a Top Choice

• Excellent leadership and community involvement programs

• High academic achievement and literacy focus

• Modern infrastructure with digital learning tools

• Supportive Catholic community

🏠 Nearby Communities
Families love living in Brock Ridge, Village East, and Duffin Heights for their proximity to St. Elizabeth Seton and strong community feel.

👉 Explore homes near St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic School

4. Father Fénelon Catholic School

📌 School Overview
Father Fénelon Catholic School stands out for its commitment to spiritual growth, academic excellence, and inclusivity. Named after the French missionary and educator François de Salignac de la Mothe-Fénelon, this school inspires students to live by the principles of compassion, wisdom, and service.

The school fosters a collaborative learning environment with programs tailored to various learning styles. Students benefit from faith-based assemblies, arts programs, athletics, and STEM projects that enhance creativity and critical thinking.

📊 Performance Snapshot (2025)

• Fraser Institute Rating: 8.9 / 10

• EQAO Math Success Rate: 93%

• Literacy Rate: 96%

• Student-Teacher Ratio: 16:1

🌟 Why It’s a Top Choice

• Excellent reputation for nurturing young learners

• Balanced curriculum with strong moral values

• High-performing teachers and engaged parents

• Great extracurricular activities and community partnerships

🏠 Nearby Communities
Top neighbourhoods include Rougemount, Amberlea, and Rosebank, offering convenient access to the school and family-friendly parks.

👉 Explore homes near Father Fénelon Catholic School

5. St. Monica Catholic School

📌 School Overview
Located in the heart of Pickering, St. Monica Catholic School is known for its nurturing environment and dedication to the intellectual, emotional, and spiritual growth of every child. It maintains a balance between academic excellence and Catholic values, ensuring that students learn with integrity and empathy.

St. Monica offers a range of extracurricular activities including music, environmental clubs, athletics, and student council. The teachers emphasize personalized learning plans to help each child thrive both in and out of the classroom.

📊 Performance Snapshot (2025)

• Fraser Institute Rating: 8.4 / 10

• EQAO Math Success Rate: 88%

• Literacy Rate: 94%

• Student-Teacher Ratio: 18:1

🌟 Why It’s a Top Choice

• Strong focus on faith-based character building

• Excellent teacher engagement and student support

• Broad extracurricular opportunities

• Safe and inclusive learning environment

🏠 Nearby Communities
Families often choose Dunbarton, Liverpool, and West Shore for their peaceful ambience and proximity to St. Monica.

👉 Explore homes near St. Monica Catholic School

🎯 Why Choose a Catholic Elementary School in Pickering?

Choosing a Catholic elementary school in Pickering offers families the perfect mix of academic success, moral development, and community connection. These schools go beyond textbooks - they nurture kindness, respect, and leadership qualities, helping children grow into well-rounded individuals.

Pickering’s Catholic schools are also deeply integrated with the local community, encouraging service, social awareness, and inclusivity from an early age. Parents appreciate the smaller class sizes, teacher commitment, and opportunities for faith-based learning.

Whether you’re a family moving to Pickering or already part of the community, investing in Catholic education ensures your child receives both intellectual and spiritual guidance for a bright future.

🏡 Find Homes Near the Best Catholic Schools in Pickering

If you’re considering relocating to ensure your child gets the best start in education, Broko makes your home search effortless. With our easy-to-use platform, you can:

✅ Discover homes near top-rated Catholic schools
✅ Compare neighbourhoods and school rankings
✅ View property details, pricing, and commute times
✅ Make informed real estate decisions - all in one place

👉 Explore all Pickering school zones and nearby homes on Broko

🌟 Final Thoughts

The Top 5 Catholic Elementary Schools in Pickering (2025) - St. Mary, St. Isaac Jogues, St. Elizabeth Seton, Father Fénelon, and St. Monica - represent the best in faith-based education, community engagement, and academic success.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or a parent planning your next move, Broko helps you align your real estate decisions with your child’s educational needs. Explore our listings, discover the top schools, and find your perfect home near Pickering’s most trusted Catholic schools.

👉 Start your search on Broko today